Who can't sing?
Ukiss - Dongho
96(8.1%)
Infinite - Sungyeol
80(6.7%)
Beast - Godwoon
49(4.1%)
T-ara - Qri
146(12.3%)
2pm - Changsung
143(12.0%)
Zea - Kwanghee
162(13.6%)
Snsd - Yoona
146(12.3%)
Kara - Hara
183(15.4%)
Wonder Girls - Sohee
122(10.3%)
Son Dambi
60(5.1%)
source: arirangworld@yt
who the crap came up with this list, why is Son Namshin aka Godwoon aka Dongwoon aka my namjachigu even in this list?! and ranked so high as well GURRRRRRRRRRRRRRL yall need to check yo facts. Also Sohee?!?! gurl's range is obviously in the lower ranges
list is automatically invalid
imo this is not even decent singing, he's singing better than half of the kpop lol
Good for Hyuna not being on the list somehow, lol poor Dambi though.
Yoona and Sohee can't sing though, I love em to bits but they can't. Any random person on the street can sing like that, but it's okay because Yoona is one of the better dancers in kpop.
Edited at 2013-02-11 06:08 pm (UTC)
and i thought qri is the one that can sing in t-ara guess i mistook her for soyeon
The funniest thing I got out of it was this comment on an I'm Really Hurt performance claiming that Qri should get more singing parts because her voice is SUPERB. Uh.... orz
(Also, the song has a similar feel to GNAAL and is the same key, so playing them together feels kind of coherent.)
sometimes
I feel it's unfair to judge Dongho, Kwanghee and Sungyeol simply because I've never heard them sing before. They have very small parts in their title songs - though ofc that's probably cause of their lack of singing talent. But how will they improve if they're never challenged?
I absolutely disagree with Dongwoon being on this list. I only got into Beast recently so I can't speak about Dongwoon in the beginning, but right now Beast is easily one of the most vocally cohesive and talented groups promoting. Dongwoon's parts in Fiction are no joke and he delivers them just as well live as any other member, plus his singing voice has a great vocal tone to it.
Now what would be fun is a list of idols who can hold a tune but should not be allowed to call themselves singers. Oh the shade I would throw.
Edited at 2013-02-11 06:30 pm (UTC)
he's gotten better since they debuted though!!!
And honestly, if we're talking about an SNSD member who can't sing live, my vote goes to Tiffany. baby girl is my bias and all but she makes me cringe way more than the dance line ever does. seriously, wtf is going on with her now