4:51 pm - 09/19/2019

Mnet Queendom Ep 4 Performances

Oh My Girl - Destiny (by Lovelyz)



(G)-Idle - Fire (2NE1)


Lovelyz - Sixth Sense (by Brown Eyed Girls)


[Full Performance Cams]





What was your favorite performance?

Oh My Girl - Destiny
40(74.1%)
(G)-Idle - Fire
9(16.7%)
Lovelyz - Sixth Sense
5(9.3%)


source: Mnet K-Pop

Results of the round will be shown next week!
(also sorry, i totally forgot about the livestream post)
Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>
torontok 19th-Sep-2019 03:16 pm (UTC)
I said on episode 1 that I wish OMG did more with the traditional concept and they came through with that this week.the chore for Mimi's part was especially cool. Was YooA injured?

Lovelyz redeemed themselves from their lackluster first eke performance but I feel like it fell flat. Kei has a lovely voice but the power wasn't there and Sixth's Sense's best parts have always been the rap break and chorus. Baby Soul sounded great.Jisoo and Mijoo suited it best.

G-(Idle) really suited the song.Soyeon should have left the bindi in the dressing room . Her,Minnie and Soojin were killer this week. Yuqi's part was so good, I love her voice
myungung 19th-Sep-2019 03:31 pm (UTC)
Same re bindi. It wasn’t needed. And what was that yodelling during the dance break?!
yuwkon 19th-Sep-2019 03:18 pm (UTC)
I EAT WHAT I SAID ABOUT GIDLE'S STAGE PRESENCE BEFORE AHKSDJFHAKDSFH IM LIVING FOR THIS FIRE VERSION! GIDLE'S ON FIRE! EVERYONE'S ON POINT! and i think this is the concept where the girls have their common ground. everybody seems to fit in this concept. I CONTINUE TO STAN.

edit: i just finished watching OMG's perf... and i think im changing my mind. it's so goooooood!

Edited at 2019-09-19 03:26 pm (UTC)
dior_chic 19th-Sep-2019 03:19 pm (UTC)
Oh My Girl did really well, Binnie’s deeper vocals are so nice! The performance overall was really well done and a mature take on Destiny :)

I’m gonna sound harsh but I didn’t really finish the other two performances. They still put in a lot of effort, I can recognize that! But idk all I can think when I watched is I’d rather watch the real thing. In the end of the day, they aren’t the Brown Eyed Girls or 2NE1. I still love both groups, don’t get me wrong!! But the senior groups they covered just had that special it factor I didn’t see in these covers.
love_keiko 19th-Sep-2019 03:30 pm (UTC)
ITA with that last part.

BEG is tough shoes to fill for sure but gidle should've done WAY better with 2NE1, esp given their image. it just didnt hit as hard for me.
love_keiko 19th-Sep-2019 03:27 pm (UTC)
oh my girl did EXCELLENT. the whole arrangement and performance was beautifully done. HUGE step up from last week--- they're the best of this bunch for me.

i'm disappointed in gidle's performance of fire. frankly, there are better 2NE1 songs and it feels like they missed out on an opportunity to show a diff side of themselves. the performance was vocally meh, sloppy (minus the 2 main members) and reductive as hell considering what we've seen from them AND 2NE1 as a group.

lovelyz put on a MUCH better show from last week and i feel like the members who could bring it, def brought it. but they're still lackluster as hell as a group, especially on a BEG track AND one as strong as sixth sense. i do commend them for going REALLY far out their comfort zone and reaching for something impactful and different from their usually look/ sound.

lil_poisonfrog 21st-Sep-2019 04:10 pm (UTC)
That's what sucks about Lovelyz on this show. I appreciate that they're willing to take risks, and if they weren't being directly compared to the others, their perfs would be just fine. I think they have the talent but are lacking proper guidance. You can't jump from innocent/pastel/feminine concepts to sth like Sixth Sense overnight. Ia with ppl saying they should've picked an SNSD or Kara song instead

Edited at 2019-09-21 04:20 pm (UTC)
belintuchiha 19th-Sep-2019 03:32 pm (UTC)
The Sixth Sense cover was flat but like they did good within the group's capacities, that's one of the hardest songs and if you can't nail the climax, don't do it lol but gotta congratulate them for their courage and effort.
You could see everyone's surprise/worry faces when they realized it was Sixth Sense.
myungung 19th-Sep-2019 03:35 pm (UTC)
OMG came through! I was a little disappointed with their first performance and felt it was the weakest, and they delivered this week with the style.

Lovelyz tried, but not everybody could do it. Sujeong has a good voice and she’s good, but I felt she and Kei didn’t fit it.

The less said about g-idle the better I guess. I was expecting something special from them but it kinda fell flat, like there was nothing special. But miyeon and minnie are doing well and shining in the past 2 performances

My ranking would be aoa>omg>>lovelyz>G-idle>Mamamoo>bom
telepathic 19th-Sep-2019 03:42 pm (UTC)
lol awkward @ OMG outdoing lovelyz right in front of them
vintage_boom 19th-Sep-2019 03:49 pm (UTC)
OMG really killed it, them and AOA were the winners for this round to me. Are OMG comebacks similar to this style? I know I've checked them out a while ago but don't remember it being like this.

(G) Idle were really charismatic but the perf kinda felt not nearly as grounded as the more veteran groups. hopefully next round they'll feel more comfortable. Yuqi's hair tho is adorable as hell.
dior_chic 19th-Sep-2019 03:52 pm (UTC)
‘Are OMG comebacks similar to this style?’

imo not really. This performance did a great job showing the range these girls have, this came off as more...raw? (Idk if that’s the right word lol) Id say what they performed in the first episode is more typical of their style. I hope since the group is getting older, their company will put out something like this! It would be nice progression in their style

Edited at 2019-09-19 03:53 pm (UTC)
lydzi 19th-Sep-2019 04:19 pm (UTC)
I can't watch korean shows because the way they always cut the performances to show again and again the reactions. Like.. I can't. Let me watch the all damn thing and then we'll get the reactions idk. It gets on my nerve.
torontok 19th-Sep-2019 05:04 pm (UTC)
they have the full versions without the editing
digitalqueen 19th-Sep-2019 04:25 pm (UTC)
gidle gets away with so much for some reason
goshipgurl 19th-Sep-2019 09:00 pm (UTC)
i'm surprised that almost no one in the comments mentions the bindi and the war cry. BP for example got called out for it but somehow it's okay when g-idle do it...
synatri 19th-Sep-2019 04:58 pm (UTC)
oh my girl went full vixx for their perf, dang! and binnie's extensions and letting her use her lower register!! though it's so awkward when it cuts to lovelyz watching them.

g-idle's felt kind of... too rehearsed? it fell kind of flat for me.

lovelyz... tried. that chorus was so high pitched it just didn't work. jisoo and mijoo were bringing it though.
maknaeroli 19th-Sep-2019 05:32 pm (UTC)
I read the comments before watching so I thought lovelyz wasn’t gonna be bad but I really didn’t think it was? Like obviously they’re no beg and no one can truly cover that song to perfection the way the original group sings it but I really thought it was ok lol!! Their voices were very good and Jisoo ROCKED IT!!!

OMG had a twist on destiny and I liked it but it definitely still sounded like destiny lol!!
volume1995 19th-Sep-2019 05:44 pm (UTC)
none of these performances really stood out to me cause i never really got into lovelyz and omg's rendition of destiny wasn't my cup of tea either so aoa is the ultimate winner of this show

gi-dles instrumental was made in garageband and it shows. they couldve done so much more with clap your hands or maybe even i am the best but this was all so cheap and soyeon girl the bindi! what the hell!

lovelyz version of sixth sense was... something. why didnt they do an oh my girl song? they couldve done checkmate from their 5th season album? or maybe aing if they wanted to play it safe?
pinklunacy 19th-Sep-2019 05:49 pm (UTC)
OMG were amazing and got my vote. At first, I was afraid I was just being biased but I'm glad a lot of people loved their performance. This type of traditional concept really suits them! It gives a new edge to their usual airy style.

The other performances weren't bad but I couldn't get into them. I didn't finish Fire and I skipped some parts of Sixth Sense, just to check the bridge. Which fell a little flat. Sixth Sense is one of my fav kpop song tho, so my expectations were probably a little high!!!

Edited at 2019-09-19 10:31 pm (UTC)
camouflagecat 19th-Sep-2019 06:07 pm (UTC)
The vocals in Sixth Sense were actually surprisingly good but they lacked so much oomph that it just fell flat compared to the original and the energy the performance was supposed to portray.
(LOL @ the guy's face 0:16 tho, he was #shook).

G-Idle did okay, but the arrangement was weird for me.

I guess because I had expectations of these two and they didn't quite meet them so in that sense OMG did the best, tho I didn't have much thoughts on their stage.
Page 1 of 2
<<[1] [2] >>
This page was loaded Oct 14th 2019, 4:40 am GMT.