hello 태태 (rockerista03) wrote in omonatheydidnt,
hello 태태

Seventeen's "Left & Right" accused of plagiarising "Cupid Shuffle"

ReacttotheK, a popular Youtube channel run by classical musician Umu and famous for their "Classical Musicians React" series to K-Pop songs, also gave their 2 cents about the issue:

The rest of the thread:

Based on his tweet, Cupid seems mostly concerned with the beat sample and pattern sounding all too similar. There have been some questions about what does "sample" mean so I'm gonna break it down!

There are two main types of samples people in the music business will refer to 1. A sample of a melody. You need a license and to pay a fee to use this and 2. A sample that is downloaded to a music program. Samples (2) like this are downloaded into a program like Logic or Ableton and then applied to make electronic sounds like drums or other electronic instruments. Because these live in universal programs, samples cannot be copywritten. After listening to them, I decided what sounds like happened is the producers for L&R used a similar (or the same) sample beat to create their own. But again there is nothing wrong w/ this bc sample beats cannot be copywritten. Albeit, the drum tracks do sound similar, there is enough difference (in my opinion) for this NOT TO BE copyright infringement. Because drum samples and patterns cannot be copywritten, the case is very weak. This is obviously not a thread going into musical analysis but is looking at the case solely from a business view. Many cases about drum loops have been brought forward but many end the same: there's enough originality to separate the two. Unfortunately, Cupid felt taken advantage of enough to make a claim (socially) and I don't want to discredit that. But looking simply at the business, it's going to be very tough to prove this case.

Source: @NEWCUPID (1, 2), @reacttothek (1, 2), @breadbabiee

The hardcore stans camping under his tweets... :/ Anyway, thoughts Omona?

EDIT: Included two new tweets from Umu + another thread from a Music degree holder. Thank you juhli for granting me permission!
Tags: foreign celebrities, plagiarism, seventeen, social media/youtube

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for members only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

← Ctrl ← Alt
Ctrl → Alt →
← Ctrl ← Alt
Ctrl → Alt →